Three Rows Twice

A feed pages with ORDER BY created_at DESC LIMIT 3 OFFSET ?. The table holds these rows.

id created_at
p9 10:09
p8 10:08
p7 10:07
p6 10:06
p5 10:05
p4 10:04

The client fetches page 1 with OFFSET 0 and receives p9, p8, p7. While the user reads, two posts arrive: p10 at 10:10 and p11 at 10:11. The client then fetches page 2 with OFFSET 3. What comes back?

A

p9, p8, p7

B

p8, p7, p6

C

p6, p5, p4

D

p11, p10, p9